Engaging London

How collaboration builds community trust in urban development

Ariel view of concrete tower blocks next to low-rise housing with red roofs, with green space around their base
Renewal at the Alton Estate in Roehampton: Image courtesy of Richmond and Wandsworth Council

After leading three co-design workshops and speaking to over 30 community engagement experts for our Engaging London project, AZUL CASTANEDA explains why involving residents is so important for place-shaping decisions. Here are three practical ideas to enhance engagement.

We know community engagement is hit and miss. Even well-intentioned efforts do not guarantee a positive impact on the people who engage in the process or the places they are shaping.

Our Engaging London programme set out to understand how the sector can collaborate more meaningfully with local communities. With 35 community representatives, designers, local authority officers, consultants, developers and other sector experts, we co-designed three practical, place-based ideas for better community engagement.

Community engagement often lacks purpose

Through my academic research, I have found several studies of community engagement in urban development that show participation is frequently framed as a procedural requirement. They often lack clarity of purpose, scope or influence on decisions, which can feel tokenistic rather than transformative.

In the absence of clear links between community input and outcomes, engagement risks functioning primarily as a tool for validation rather than addressing conflict and shaping better places.

“The term community engagement itself involves power relationships – someone is being engaged,” says Pablo Sendra, Professor of Urban Design and Public Participation at The Bartlett School of Planning. “It implies someone with power doing the engaging, and this has certain limitations.”

Rebalancing power in favour of communities

Power relations became a central theme in our workshops. We found that genuine engagement cannot be reduced to a single event or consultation model. Instead, effective collaboration needs common values, real power-sharing, and a focus on long-term relationships. Taken together, these points point toward a shift from traditional, institution-led approaches to something much more collaborative and place-based.

Participants were also candid about the barriers to community involvement. They described how engagement is often constrained by limited resources, competing agendas, and the persistent challenge of inclusion and representation.

These are not new concerns. Rather, they reflect accumulated experiences among our project participants of development that does not respond to local knowledge or priorities. We heard that communities often approach new community engagement cautiously because previous involvement has not led to visible change.

Rethinking decision-making with communities

A person in a grey dress and a red lanyard talks in front of a large screen
Azul Castaneda facilitates an Engaging London workshop

Our Engaging London research included 25 interviews and three co-design workshops to identify new approaches to sector-wide change based on participants’ lived experience of consultation.

Participants emphasised the need to rethink how agency and decision-making are shared between the state and citizens, moving beyond token involvement towards more active roles for communities.

“One of the things we are seeing today is the limits of what government can do,” said Stephen Hill, of C2O futureplanners. “The things that really matter to people are not really getting addressed because the expectations we had post-war of what the state can do are kind of over.

“We need to reimagine the role of the state and the citizen. We are talking about new tools for enabling citizens to play a constructive and active part – people will take responsibility because they can.”

Rebuilding community trust at the Alton estate

Alton’s community panel was created to address a constant tension between developers, the local authority, and community members. Now, the council has enabled residents to share their views and knowledge, giving them real influence on the Alton Renewal Plan. This had a positive impact on the regeneration project. “The community panel on the Alton feel they’ve got power and a voice, and I think they do genuinely have agency through the democratic set-up of the council,” explains Kate Batchelor, Head of Place Programme at Wandsworth and Richmond Councils.

Three ideas for enabling community collaboration

From these discussions, three strong ideas emerged to support a shift from participation as a procedural exercise to collaboration that shares responsibility and influence that builds trust and resident long-term involvement.

1. The transparency manifesto

There is a growing recognition that trust and accountability are central to successful development, which creates places where people want to live. But converting this insight into action is frequently undermined by the absence of quality benchmarks. The transparency manifesto sets out a practical, sector-led accreditation framework for development and regeneration.

Based on Future of London’s co-production principles and informed by models such as B Corp and the Stonewall Index, the manifesto would show how to demonstrate transparent decision-making, knowledge-sharing, and meaningful community collaboration.

By defining good practice, the accreditation would help unlock stronger community relationships, reducing conflict and delay. For development partners, it offers a common reference point for improving practice, recognising progress, and building confidence. Transparency would become a strategic advantage that supports trust and delivers better long-term outcomes.

2. The local knowledge store

The second idea responds to a widely recognised problem: local place-based knowledge gathered through community engagement is fragmented, inconsistently recorded, and often lost over time.

As project teams change and information becomes siloed within organisations, communities are repeatedly asked to share the same insights about their area and its priorities. Participants described this as “knowledge extraction”, where valuable local knowledge is taken but not retained. This repetition weakens trust and contributes to engagement that feels transactional and exhausting.

The proposed local knowledge store would bring together insights generated through previous community engagement processes in one accessible place, helping anyone seeking to work in or understand a local area to engage more thoughtfully and responsibly.

A shared information hub, imagined as a wiki-style, multimedia repository for locally relevant knowledge, would be combined with opportunities to develop social relationships, such as place walks or shared meals. This approach recognises that local knowledge lives in people and relationships, not just documents.

Over time, the platform would build a shared memory of the place. The local knowledge store provides a flexible model, with funding and governance adapted to local contexts – for example, through BIDs, neighbourhood forums or community-led partnerships.

3. The place space

Building on the local knowledge store concept, the place space is a space for residents, community groups, institutions, local representatives and local organisations to collaborate around the shared needs and aspirations for a place.

Rather than being hosted by a single organisation, the place space would rotate, drawing on existing networks and spaces. This structure naturally widens participation and brings in new voices and perspectives.

The place space would have enough structure to focus on the place while still giving each host the freedom to set the agenda. Sessions could range from problem-solving workshops to storytelling lunches, memory sharing, mapping exercises, or explorations of emerging local issues.

The aim is to strengthen local relationships, build resilience, and create the conditions for collaboration. Over time, as more groups participate, the place space would become an ecosystem of local connections that would mobilise when major developments or challenges arise.

So, what’s next?

Three people sit at table strewn with post-it notes and glasses, with one pointing with a pen
Bettisabel Lamelo of Arup leads a table discussion

The Engaging London programme will conclude with a sector-wide event at the end of 2026. We will invite the wider built environment sector to engage with the findings, reflect on what is realistically achievable, and openly challenge the ideas presented.

The aim is to test that the ideas emerging from Engaging London are grounded, relevant and capable of driving practical change in how engagement is approached across the sector.

“We have proposed a solution for more meaningful engagement, but how do we move forward?” asks Bettisabel Lamelo, Participatory Design Service Lead at Arup. ”

“Rather than establishing a rigid structure, we could allow ideas to develop organically. We could act as champions for the concepts we’ve developed, leveraging our different networks to advance them. We can come together later to reflect on our progress and see how our achievements can create momentum for further delivery.”

We do not pretend to offer simple solutions to long-standing challenges in community engagement. However, Engaging London has developed tangible proposals shaped through the collective thinking of practitioners, policymakers and community-facing experts.

The programme has surfaced new insights, strengthened relationships and created a shared commitment to doing things differently. Real progress now depends on whether councils, communities, organisations and industry leaders recognise that meaningful engagement requires sustained effort buy-in and, ultimately, system change.

Azul Castaneda is a Future of London associate and a PhD candidate at the Open University with the Open-Oxford-Cambridge AHRC DTP-funded Collaborative Doctoral Award, researching community engagement in the built environment sector.

Thanks to Arup and Pollard Thomas Edwards for supporting Engaging London.