Don’t underestimate the complexity of small site housing

Local authorities should approach housing development on small sites with the same rigour as larger projects, according to our expert panel. Here’s their advice on managing the risks and creating value.

Small site development at Constable Road and Rembrandt drive, Gravesham, BPTW

Small sites are crucial to London’s housing targets but despite their diminutive size they can be as complex as larger schemes. Access, procurement and viability are common challenges.

At a recent Council‑Led Housing Network expert panel, speakers warned that people often underestimate the challenges of small sites. When treated as low risk, schemes can stall and drain resources, an increasing concern as councils face tighter borrowing limits and less capacity to deliver directly.

David Meecham, partner at TLT outlined this from a legal perspective: “Just because a site is small doesn’t mean it’s simple. Legal and development constraints can still be complex – so take time to understand the risks and how you can de‑risk the site before going to market. “The expert panellists urged councils to be clear about procurement thresholds, contract structures and risk allocation, and to address key legal constraints early to ensure the best opportunities for bidders.

What is clear is that successful small‑site programmes start with strong upfront analysis. Before progressing small sites, councils need a clear picture of what they own, where sites are located and the constraints they carry. They also need to think carefully about what they actually want to deliver.

Councils can waste a lot of money by progressing small sites too far without properly testing feasibility, legal constraints and access. Begin with light‑touch feasibility work. Desktop reviews and site visits can quickly surface risks around ownership, access, utilities and planning policy, helping councils avoid committing resources too early.

More detailed surveys and design work should only follow once a site demonstrates a strong likelihood of progressing, reducing the risk of abortive costs across the programme.

Clear programme objectives are not to be underestimated either, and are central to the success of any small sites project. These objectives might be focused on speed, tenure mix, placemaking or income and they are essential in shaping appropriate delivery models.

Clustering and packaging

A key theme of the expert led discussion was the value of clustering and packaging sites. Grouping small sites into portfolios can create scale, improve management efficiency and make opportunities more attractive to the market.

Clusters of around 25 to 30 homes, or eight to 10 sites, are often needed to generate developer interest. Clustering can also enable cross‑subsidy between sites with different constraints, supporting overall programme viability.

“There’s no single formula for success, but there are proven good practices. When packaging sites, investing time in understanding and de‑risking them can make a real difference in attracting contractors or developers,” says Neil Campbell, partner at BPTW. “It’s not a silver bullet, but a combination of strong preparation and flexibility in what you deliver across sites goes a long way.”

With the SME developer market currently constrained, councils need to make small‑site opportunities as clear and deliverable as possible. Providing transparent information, reducing unnecessary complexity and packaging sites intelligently can help improve take‑up.

According to the experts, success on small sites comes from a thoughtful and considered practice. Apply the same discipline as larger schemes, they say, while keeping delivery simple and pragmatic. This approach gives councils the best chance of unlocking much‑needed opportunities for housing delivery.

Council housing expert panel